The Bull Cup is a sterling silver bowl approximately 10 cm in diameter and 6 cm in height, which is mounted on a tapered square wood base with a natural wood finish.
The main plate on the base is inscribed The Bull Cup - The BLBA, referring to the former acronym of the league (Bull League Baseball Association).
Beginning in 2016, the annual team panels will be in the format:
- WINNING TEAM NAME
- SERIES SCORE
- LOSING TEAM NAME
Existing panels will be changed to the new panel format.
The trophy was made by Ace Awards of Toronto, Canada.